讨论车尔尼599的装饰音

想和大家讨论下怎么处理 第95条的装饰音？弹在拍前（先弹右手的装饰音）还是拍点上（左手与右手同时）？

我弹的，你说的后者，在拍点上，不知对不对： [flash]http://www.tudou.com/v/AJ411ANe6jU/v.swf[/media]

教学视频说装饰音占之前的拍子。http://www.tudou.com/programs/view/uk9Zbl6np6A/?fr=rec1

我正在综合第72条后的各种装饰音，周末请教老师。

http://www.oldflutes.com/articles/kurze/ 摘自以上网文： The short appoggiatura is usually performed in modern music as a very short note inserted before the time of the main note. However, it was expected to be played in the time of the main note (on-beat) throughout the 19th century and into the 20th. It is often heard misinterpreted by performers of 19th century music. 费了好大劲儿网上各种research，终于有了比较满意的答案，还是期望与大家继续探讨具体实例。

鱼儿的方法正确，拍手～～～～

以下是引用estella78在2014-3-10 12:05:00的发言：
鱼儿的方法正确，拍手～～～～

我是天才

 女儿练完这首了

以下是引用estella78在2014-3-16 14:41:00的发言：
 女儿练完这首了

[全屏欣赏]

不要学死了。我是拍前、拍后都练了。